-->
  • Most Respected Classical Music Platform
  • #classicalForever
BREAKING
Kennedy Center President Deborah F. Rutter to Step Down
TOP
Liang Wang (Image- NY Phil)

Court Dismisses NY Phil Former Oboist's Defamation Suit Against NY Magazine and Reporter

Liang Wang’s lawsuit against two media outlets and an investigative reporter has been dismissed by the U.S. District Court

 

In April 2024, the investigative reporter Sammy Sussman released an article in Vulture, a part of New York Magazine, that raised serious sexual assault allegations against oboist Liang Wang and trumpeter Matthew Muckey of the New York Philharmonic

A month later, Wang sued Sussman; Sussman’s publisher, New York Media; and NY Media’s parent company, Vox Media, for defamation. 

Wang has since been suspended from his principal post in the NY Phil alongside Muckey.

Though Wang sought $100 million in damages, his case against the defendants was recently dismissed by the U.S. District Court — Southern District of New York.

Referring to Sussman’s article and a podcast episode in which Sussman discusses it, Wang’s suit claims that the former “wrongly depicts him as committing and being fired for a specific incident of sexual misconduct.”

Wang further argues that the article and podcast are defamatory due to their supposed false statements of fact, and their inference of defamation due to “false suggestions, impressions and implications arising from otherwise truthful statements.”

In a court document prepared by the U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian, it is explained that under New York law, a defamation plaintiff (in this case, Wang) must show a defamatory statement of fact concerning the plaintiff; publication to a third party; fault; falsity of the defamatory statement; and specific financial losses or harmful actions.

Subramanian writes that “Wang fails to plausibly allege a claim of express defamation.”

“If anything, [the statements in the podcast] seem to indicate that Sussman is trying, albeit unsuccessfully, to differentiate the allegations against Wang and those Kizer made against Muckey,” Subramanian concluded in the court document. “To make a showing of intent, Wang needs more.”

The Clerk of Court was directed to close the case.

upcoming events

february 2025

07febAll Day17International "Franz Schubert and Modern Music” Chamber Music Competition(All Day) Universität für Musik und darstellende Kunst Graz, Leonhardstraße 15, A-8010 GrazEvent Type :competitions Event TagsInternational "Franz Schubert and Modern Music” Piano Trio Competition

14febAll Day22Jascha Heifetz International Violin Competition(All Day) Lithuanian National Philharmonic Hall, Aušros Vartų g. 5 Vilnius, LithuaniaEvent Type :competitions Event TagsInternational Jascha Heifetz Competition for Violinists

16febAll DayChicago National Chamber Music Competition(All Day: sunday) Ravinia’s Bennett Gordon Hall, 201 St Johns Ave, Highland Park, IL 60035, United StatesEvent Type :competitions Event Tagschamber music,competition

march 2025

15marAll DayMusic Teachers National Association (MTNA) National Conference(All Day: saturday) Hilton Minneapolis, 1001 Marquette Ave. Event Type :conferences & tradeshows Event Tagschamber music,Chamber Music America,Conferences,Music Teachers National Association National Conference

18marAll DayJohansen International String Competition(All Day: tuesday) Calvary Baptist Church, 755 8th Street, NW, Washington, DCEvent Type :competitions

19marAll DayAmerican String Teachers Association (ASTA) National Conference(All Day: wednesday) HYATT REGENCY ATLANTA, 265 Peachtree St Event Type :conferences & tradeshows Event TagsAmerican String Teachers Association,American String Teachers Association National Conference,ASTA,conference

CONTACT US
x

Get ALL our latest conveniently by EMAIL

Our newsletter is trusted by over 100,000+ industry professionals around the world

We deliver news straight to your inbox and will never share your data.
You'll never miss a beat!

click left click right